The Voice vs. American Idol
The Voice’s Top 4-Javier Colon, Dia Frampton, Vicci Martinez, Beverly McClellan
American Idol’s Top 11-Scotty McCreery, Casey Abrams, Haley Reinhart, Jacob Lusk, James Durbin, Karen Rodriguez, Paul McDonald, Lauren Alaina, Stefano Langone, Pia Toscano, Thia Megia
The Voice was one of many shows that tried to compete with American Idol and I actually enjoyed it. There were some great moments (especially when the contestants performed with their coaches), but overall there is a reason “American Idol” continues to be the most watched show year in and year out (like the epic finale). One reason is the pool of talent. American Idol goes out to all these cities and hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of people try out every year. The Voice seemed to choose from a much smaller pool and it showed. The different concepts of the voice were pretty cool with the coaches and the battle rounds, but it lacked the talent to really be amazing. From day one, we knew who was going to win The Voice, and that is never the case with American Idol.
In my opinion, only one person in the top four of The Voice (Javier Colon) would have made it into the top 11 on American Idol. Some people may argue that Dia and Vicci would have made it to the top 11, my counter would be that Thia and Pia were the 11th and 10th contestants voted off of “American Idol.” They are all attractive female artists with interesting voices, but Thia and Pia had more powerful voices, they were more attractive, and they both had more star potential. (Pia already has a record deal and she was 10th this season on American Idol)
That leads us to another problem with The Voice-the coaches seemed to feel sorry for the contestants instead of treat them like artists. This was evidenced by Adam Levine’s comments that this show was not about potential but about giving Javier Colon (failed artists) a last shot at making it big. While I believe Javier was the right decision, I also believe he had way more potential. That’s what we want out of these shows, potential stars. I think Adams ideals shone bright in Christina Aguilera’s final two team members who were older bald women that have already tried and failed in the music industry. Only Blake Shelton seemed to get the idea of trying to form a voice out of a young talent with potential. Did it work? I guess not because “Team Adam” won. Also, I didn’t get the whole team thing and why it mattered that Adam won, what did he get? (Besides bragging rights against Christina which he already has because he is obviously way cooler)
The best punch The Voice threw (besides the coach/contestant collaborations) is that Javier Colon was better than any contestant on American Idol since Carrie Underwood. That bald dude with the hat can really make your knees weak (yeah maybe even mine). He has the voice of an angel and I would bet any amount of money that he becomes more successful than Scotty McCreery (whom I love and hope he succeeds because he seems like a really good, humble kid with a nice deep country voice). I believe they will both be pretty successful, but Javier has something special and The Voice discovered him.
The best two things about The Voice that I would draft 1 and 2 in a singing contest show draft would be a winner like Javier Colon and a judge/coach like Adam Levine (cool, suave, knows what he is talking about, comes out with new hits during the show, can still perform, rips on people, is funny, and wins). Number 3-100 would be “American Idol” people, probably starting with Jlo because she’s gorgeous plus most of the things I praised Adam for and the show couldn’t run without Seacrest so he would probably be next.
All in all I thought The Voice was alright, but “American Idol’s” spot at the top is safe for now, I can’t wait to see what Simon Cowell’s X-Factor has in store.
P.S. I still wish Paul McDonald would have won!